The origin of bubonic plague
Although some forms of the bacterium Yersinia are harmless, other forms have devastated human populations, causing a plague of biblical proportions (Psalm 91:3-7, Psalm 91:9-10,). Bubonic plague, also known as the ‘Black Death’ that killed one fourth of Europe’s population in the 1300s, appeared as a great pestilence several times in the Old Testament, including in Psalm 91 and in 2 Samuel 24:14-25. Perhaps the clearest example of such a plague is recorded in 1 Samuel 6:4-19, where there is a specific reference to the tumors on people (bubos = the tumors of lymph glands) and to rats (the animal vector that carried the plague bacterium, Yersinia pestis.) The biblical time frame for the plagues described in 1 Samuel was about 3,000 years ago.1
Interestingly, experts on plague ‘evolution’ estimate the emergence of Y. pestis at about 1,500-20,000 years ago (within an evolutionary timeframe, of course).2
Plague’s origin is multifaceted
Many infectious diseases can be traced back to the decay and corruption of the original created design of microorganisms as a result of the Fall. Corruption literally means to destroy (from the Latin corruptus). The origin of pathogenic (disease-causing) bacteria such as Y. pestis is complex and multifaceted, and may be explained by a combination of genes that were lost, added and moved. The story of Yersinia’s degeneration into the plague pathogen may serve as a model of ‘fast’ genomic decay and corruption.2
It appears that the beginning of pathogenicity in the genus Yersinia started with a net loss of chromosomal DNA from its original ‘kind’ (figure 1). Later, there were minor additions of plasmid DNA3 as well as DNA from viruses and other bacteria. A few plasmid genes for toxins (table 1) have been acquired from another existing species, but many chromosomal genes have been lost. It takes only a few such genetic changes to produce a new, extremely infectious variant,4 so it may have taken only hundreds or a few thousand years to produce the current bubonic plague strain that has existed for about the last 500 years.
Loss of chromosomal DNA
Figure 1. Origin of plague: the decay and corruption of nonpathogenic Yersinia to highly virulent Y. pestis in a few thousand years. Click here for larger view
Researchers hypothesize that key chromosomal genes (i.e. involved in metabolic pathways) were inactivated/lost in changing from a soil-inhabiting Yersinia to a pathogenic Yersinia species.2 Pathogenic Yersiniae have lost structural information and function in about 149 genes. Of these, 58 are the result of frameshift mutations,5 32 have undergone deletions, and the rest are nonsense mutations.6 These incomplete/inactivated genes or ‘pseudogenes’ are an important feature of the Y. pestis genome.7 Wren2 suggests that the genes lost in Y. pestis affected bioenergetic functions, including dicarboxylic amino-acid metabolism. This reduction of metabolic pathways may have allowed the bacterium to conserve energy. The newly emerged strains (variants) were thus streamlined, which might have contributed to the development of pathogenicity (i.e. plague) due to the genes they lacked. The absence of important biosynthetic genes is believed to be a hallmark of genome decay.
Genes added and moved
The corruption by three genes of a relatively benign recent ancestor of Y. pestis may have played a key role in the emergence of bubonic plague. Hinnebusch and colleagues, a plague expert team at the National Institutes for Health,8 maintains that the acquisition of two plasmid genes (i.e. just a few discrete genetic changes) in recent times changed the fairly harmless, Y. pseudotuberculosis, that causes mild food poisoning, to the agent of the ‘Black Death’. A third gene (carried on plasmid pMT1) produces murine toxin, an enzyme required for the initial survival of Y. pestis bacilli in the flea midgut (table 1).7 By acquiring this last gene from another organism, Y. pestis made a crucial shift in its host range, allowing it to survive in fleas, and devolved to relying on its blood-feeding host for transmission. This is just another example of the flexibility of many microbes in sometimes repackaging themselves into more dangerous agents of infectious disease.
This last corruption is one that distinguishes Yersinia pestis from all closely related, more benign bacteria such as Y. pseudotuberculosis and other Yersinia (e.g. Y. entercolitica).7 In turn, as Y. pestis adapted to rely on its new blood-feeding host for transmission, the emergence of more deadly bacterial strains would have been favoured. It appears that these minor plasmid additions10 were the last changes made in an otherwise long series of genetic losses in Y. pseudotuberculosis’ chromosome (figure 1).
One pathogenicity island was acquired by Yersinia pestis from a different bacterium.2 This cassette of genes was not the result of evolution of new chromosomal DNA, but was an acquisition through lateral gene transfer.11 It produced a corrupted message that gave bacteria a new ‘position’ in the gut. Y. pseudotuberculosis, which lacks the hms locus gene inhabits harmlessly the midgut of the flea. Plague bacilli, by contrast, have this inserted locus gene. Free from their original control, causing a lack of ‘good’ ‘direction’ information, the bacteria migrate from the midgut to the foregut, forming a plug of packed bacilli which is passed on to the victim when the flea feeds.
Genes, germs and Genesis
Plague bacteria are not the only microorganisms that have degenerated into disease-causing organisms. A more common recent example of a harmless bacteria ‘devolving’ into a pathogenic one is the intestinal Escherichia coli O157H7 strain that occasionally causes fatalities.12 Other pathogenic bacteria that have undergone genomic decay include various mycoplasmas (e.g. Mycoplasma genitalium and M. pneumonia, the later causing pneumonia), and Mycobacterium leprae (the leprosy bacillus).13,14
As we study the origin of infectious disease from a creationist, biblical perspective, bacteria provide us with a model of what may have happened to living things over time in a fallen, cursed and corrupted world. Many illnesses can probably be traced back to a loss of genetic information, plasmid acquisition, and gene translocation in organisms such as bacteria, fungi, etc. For those who know the Creator, we can rejoice that someday the Great Physician will restore all plagued bodies to a very good condition once again (Revelation 22:2-3).
References and notes
- Ryrie, C., Ryrie Study Bible (KJV), Moody Press, Chicago, IL, 1994. Return to text.
- Wren, B.W., The Yersiniae-a model genus to study the rapid evolution of bacterial pathogens, Nature Micro. Rev. 1(1):55-64, 2003 | PMID:15040180. Return to text.
- Plasmids are circular, double-stranded units of DNA that replicate within cells independently of the chromosomal DNA. Return to text.
- Lorange, E.A., Race, B.L., Sebbane, F. and Hinnebusch, B.J., Poor vector competence of fleas and the evolution of hypervirulence in Yersinia pestis, J. Infect. Dis. 191(11):1907-1912, 2005 | PMID: 15871125. Return to text.
- Frameshift mutations are changes in DNA where insertions or deletions of sequence occur that are not a multiple of three base pairs, thus disrupting the gene/protein normal code. Return to text.
- A nonsense mutation is any alteration of DNA that causes a codon representing an amino acid to be replaced by a termination codon. Return to text.
- Hinnebusch, B.J., Rudolph, A.E., Cherepanov, P., Dixon, J.E., Schwan, T.G., and Forsberg, A., Role of Yersinia murine toxin in survival of Yersinia pestis in the midgut of the flea vector, Science 296(5568):733-735, 2002 | PMID: 11976454. Return to text.
- Nester, E.W., et al., Microbiology: A Human Perspective, 4th ed, WCB McGraw-Hill Publishers, Boston, MA, 2004. Return to text.
- Parkhill, J., et al., Genome sequence of Yersinia pestis, the causative agent of plague, Nature 413(6855):523-527, 2001 | PMID: 11586360. Return to text.
- Hinnebusch B.J., Perry R.D. and Schwan T.G., Role of the Yersinia pestis hemin storage (hms) locus in the transmission of plague by fleas, Science 273(5273):367-370, 1996 | PMID: 8662526. Return to text.
- Lateral gene transfer is any process in which an organism transfers DNA to another cell that is not its offspring. Return to text.
- Pommerville, J.C., Alcamo’s Fundamentals of Microbiology, Jones and Bartlett Publishers, Sudbury, MA, 2004. Return to text.
- Wood, T.C., Genome decay in the Mycoplasmas, Acts and Facts Impact 340:1-4, 1981. Return to text.
- Eiglmeier, K., The decaying genome of Mycobacterium leprae, Lepr. Rev. 72(4):387-398, 2001 | PMID:1826475. Return to text.
“Disease-causing organisms” is an ambiguous description that tends to encourage us focus on and lay sole blame a microbe. The microbe is merely responding to God’s created order and it will do whatever is necessary in order to survive and complete it designated task. It accomplishes this quite well despite the roadblocks we introduce in attempt to manipulate and control it. The human anatomy on the other hand, which is considerably more complex is not doing as well, simply because it is compelled for the sake of it's existence to play host to all of these microbes that are continually trying to clean up and keep pace with “a fallen, cursed and corrupted world”.
Our bodies are host to trillions of microbes, many of which are proving to be important for our health (see, for example Food scare leads to design discovery). Many would be aware of how taking antibiotics can result in diarrhea because of the elimination of beneficial gut microbes.
The appendix is a safe-house that was designed as a safe haven for beneficial microbes that populate our gut.
And yes, the interplay between the two (microbes and man) has been subject to the decay that has happened due to the Fall, resulting in disease on occasions.
If we know that viruses and bacteria can transfer DNA and that bad bacteria and viruses are the result of lost DNA or damage DNA. Could "Natural Selection" be manipulated to add missing pieces back to pathogens to improve them so they are no longer harmful? Instead of trying to wipe them out we focus on repairing what is broken.
Trying to heal the world including bacteria and viruses is more after the Father's heart then exterminating the undesirable.
Manipulating 'natural selection' would amount to intelligent design. And yes, by intelligently engineering pathogens it might be possible to restore the original non-pathogenic type (although with the loss of genes, one would be at loss as to know what to restore, without the present availability of the non-pathogenic form that degnerated to compare with). However, there is little point in trying to restore what already exists today (the non-pathogenic parent organisms).