Also Available in:
This article is from
Creation 28(2):18–20, March 2006

Browse our latest digital issue Subscribe

Dismantle the big bang

and rediscover God’s universe

by and Carl Wieland

Big bang thinking is permeating Christianity, undermining the Gospel and leading countless souls astray. Many prominent church figures are urging people to abandon the fundamental doctrines of creation and the authority of the Bible. Leading Church of England scientist/priests, Rev. Dr Arthur Peacocke and Rev. Dr Sir John Polkinghorne KBE, FRS, are both urging the church to replace Genesis creation with big bang theory and cosmic evolution.

NASA, ESA and The Hubble Heritage Team (STScl/AURA)Ant Nebula
The Ant Nebula is approximately 1.6 light years long and part of a Milky Way constellation called Norma, some 3,000–6,000 light years away from Earth. The curious pattern of gases being ejected from the dying star results in the visible ant–like appearance though exactly how this has occurred is not yet fully understood.

According to Peacocke, the Creator is the author of processes whereby things make themselves. This very likely includes life elsewhere in the universe.1 Jesus Christ ‘represents the consummation of the evolutionary creative process that God has been effecting in and through the world … What was revealed in Jesus the Christ could also, in principle, be manifest both in other human beings and indeed also on other planets, in any sentient, self–conscious, non–human persons …’ (p. 114).2 Entirely gone is the concept of man the sinner and Christ the Saviour. Jesus is thus just a highly evolved human being, rather than God incarnate, and we can evolve as He did and become like Him.

Polkinghorne takes an approach much like this, too, and reaches similar conclusions. In a public lecture entitled ‘Is there a destiny beyond death?’ he proposed a view of eternal life in which there is no cross. Instead of the cross, he inserted purgatory as a means of making us fit to enter into the presence of God.3 I imagine that if you wanted to insult Jesus then you could hardly do better than to say that his death on the cross did not restore us to full fellowship with God and thus we will need to go through a process of purgation (cleansing) in order to achieve that end for ourselves. Yet this is the logical consequence of Polkinghorne’s big bang beginning followed by cosmic evolution. The big bang’s millions of years, with Earth cooling slowly and geological processes forming fossils, mean that death must be a natural part of life and have been around before sin. Thus death is not the penalty for sin. So Christ’s death on our behalf means nothing.

NASA,The Hubble Heritage TeamThe Reflection Nebula in the Orion constellation
The Reflection Nebula in the Orion constellation. It is about 1,500 light years from Earth and was discovered first by creationist Sir William Herschel and his wife Caroline, some two centuries ago.

Tragically, all this heresy is based on a mirage. In a powerful new book, Dismantling the Big Bang: God’s Universe Rediscovered,4 (DBB) Australian authors Alex Williams and Dr John Hartnett show us (in easy–to–read layman’s language) that the standard big bang models (there are several varieties) are simply not credible. They do not enable us to explain the origin of galaxies, stars, or planets—which is astonishing, given that the very purpose of the big bang is to explain the origin of the material universe. (Without stars and galaxies, there’s not much left of that universe, to put it mildly). In short, Peacocke and Polkinghorne are urging Christians to relinquish the genuine history of the universe and exchange it for a counterfeit.

On the other hand, the Bible does have a credible and consistent cause for all that we see around us. ‘In the beginning was the Word, the Word was with God and the Word was God. He was in the beginning with God. All things were made through him … The Word became flesh and dwelt amongst us and we beheld his glory, the glory as of the only–begotten Son of the Father’ (John 1:1–3, 14). These familiar words from John’s Gospel constitute the most powerful explanation for the origin, nature and destiny of the universe that the world has ever heard.

Cosmology belongs to the Christian

Cosmology is the study of the universe (cosmos). We humans are stuck in both space and time in a very small part of a very vast universe. We cannot traverse the universe to study its size or shape, nor can we go backwards or forwards in time to see how it changes. All we can do is contemplate it through our telescopes—and make up and compare (and try to test) stories that try to explain where it came from and how it got to be the way it is.

The standard big bang models are the most popular stories going around now, but most people don’t realize that they are just one class of many possible different kinds of narratives.

As DBB shows, some stories about the universe are better than others because they explain more. In ancient times, some thought that spirit beings moved the planets around the solar system—until the 17th century when Sir Isaac Newton discovered the laws of motion and the force of gravity.

Antonella Nota (ESA/STScl) et al.,ESA, NASA.

In the 20th century, when Edwin Hubble discovered that the universe was expanding, these same laws of gravity and motion led to the idea that in the past the galaxies must have all been together in one place, in which case gravity would have sucked everything into a state of infinitely dense and hot energy. To get out of that state, something incomprehensible must have happened. An eruption of unimaginable magnitude must have occurred—hence the name ‘big bang’.

But this ‘story’ is riddled with insoluble conundrums. For example, there is no known force in physics that could have caused the expansion of the universe out of such an initial state. Then many other things which likewise have no known cause (such as ‘inflation’) must follow later in the process. One event does not lead naturally to the next, so a multitude of incomprehensible causes have to be cobbled together to get the expansion going and to make it produce a universe. The DBB book shows that in this and other aspects, big bang theory is internally inconsistent.

In dramatic contrast, biblical cosmology is internally consistent. Its proposed cause—God—can create a universe. We know this because God the Son, Jesus Christ, came to Earth and did miracles of creation such as turning water into wine, and multiplying loaves and fishes.5 (Even a dead fish is far more complex than an entire galaxy.)

Not only does the Bible provide us with a credible cause (God) but this same cause also provides a consistent explanation for the nature and development of the world we live in. For the Word of God not only created the universe, but also upholds the universe and guides the universe to its destiny in that same Word, the person of Jesus Christ (Colossians 1:16–17). Cosmologists have discovered that the laws of physics and chemistry and the structure of the galaxy and the solar system are very finely tuned to support life on Earth. This is consistent with the idea of intelligent design. But the Bible in Genesis also explains the ‘fallen’ state of the world with its suffering and death—a result of God’s curse upon man’s sin. So a straight forward reading of the Bible explains the origin, nature and destiny of the universe in a scientifically credible and consistent manner. The authors also show that the Bible’s timescale is more credible than the billions of years of standard cosmology.

The great news from this excellent new book is that the Bible is not only a source of salvation to satisfy our souls, it is a goldmine of intellectual understanding to satisfy our minds. Jesus Christ is not just an immense figure in history, he is the Alpha and the Omega, the Beginning and the End (Revelation 22:13), and that is the greatest cosmological statement humanity is ever likely to hear.

Posted on homepage: 5 March 2007

References and notes

  1. A powerful recent book, Gary Bates’s Alien Intrusion: UFOs and the Evolution Connection, Master Books, Arkansas, USA, 2004, highlights the absence of scientific evidence for the existence of extra–terrestrial life, and gives massive evidence for a satanic effort to deceive mankind into thinking aliens exist and have arrived on earth. Return to text.
  2. Peacocke, A., Humanity’s Place in Cosmic Evolution, in Dick, S.J., (ed.) Many Worlds: The New Universe, Extra–Terrestrial Life and the Theological Implications, Templeton Foundation Press, Philadelphia, USA, pp. 89–118, 2000. Quoted in an online review at: www.faithnet.org.uk/AS%20Subjects/Philosophyofreligion/peacocke.htm, 11 October 2005. Return to text.
  3. Polkinghorne, J., Is there a destiny beyond death?, St George’s Anglican Cathedral Perth, Lecture No. 10, Western Australia, 2003. Return to text.
  4. Williams, A. and Hartnett, J.,Dismantling the Big Bang: God’s Universe Rediscovered, Master Books, Arkansas , USA, 2005. Return to text.
  5. Jesus would not have created a new star to demonstrate His power—to be appreciable, it would have had to be close enough to endanger people’s lives. Return to text.

Helpful Resources

Dismantling the Big Bang
by Alex Williams, John Hartnett
US $20.00
Soft cover