Feedback archiveFeedback 2021

Faster than Light?

Did the V838 Monocerotis explode faster than light?

Published: 21 August 2021 (GMT+10)

David S. writes in, and CMI’s Scot Devlin responds, interspersed:

I’ve just read through Dismantling the Big Bang, and on page 242 this star erupted and in 6 months it looks to have doubled in size. At the ‘Speed of Light’ could it get that big in that length of time?

Figure 1. Sequence of pictures form the NASA/ESA Hubble Space Telescopes advanced cameras shows the light echo from V838 Monocerotis’ outburst in 2002. Note that the changes in appearance of the circumstellar dust are due to sequential illumination. It is the light emanating from the dust cloud that appears to travel at superluminal velocities.

This is an interesting example: The star mentioned on page 242 of, Dismantling the Big Bang is known as V838 Monocerotis (named because it was the 838th variable star of the faint constellation Monoceros (Unicorn)). The Hubble space telescope first spotted it in 2002. Because there are still questions of how and why it erupted, V838 Monocerotis is thought to be a binary star system, i.e., two stars orbiting close together. It is in the constellation of Monoceros, 19,000 light years away.

In 2002 it erupted, becoming 600,000 times more luminous than the sun. V838 Monocerotis then expanded from a visual apparent size of 4 light years to 7 light years in less than 7 months (see Figure 1)! This increase in visual appearance is of superluminal velocity. So, the answer to your question is no, the star could not have grown that big in this length of time, because in Einstein relativity (and experimentation), nothing can travel faster than the speed of light in a vacuum.

Faster in the past?

Figure 2. A light echo: Light ray A, direct from the source (yellow star) arrives at the observer (blue dot) first. Light ray B and C reflect off the gas cloud, but because B has a shorter path it arrives at the observer first. To the observer, B and C appear to come from the same point in the sky. It therefore appears that the illumination of the gas cloud in the direction perpendicular to A is faster than the speed of light.

While a much faster speed of light in the past has been proposed to solve some of the Big Bang’s endemic problems, measurements of the two-way speed of light have always given the same results when measured from non-accelerating external reference frames.

Because the speed of light is tied to other fundamental constants (most critically the dimensionless fine structure constant), a varying speed of light in the past would have implications on what we see now unless the laws of physics were different in the past.This has been explored in the secular and creationist scientific literature.

If the speed of light has changed in the past, the change would most likely occur at a time when miracles are freely allowed.1 For Evolutionists this is the Planck era, i.e. the first 5.39 × 10-44 s of the universe, where current theories of physics are not able to make retrodictions.2 For the creationist, this is Creation Week.

Although creationists can account for a change in the speed of light (we have a miracle worker), most creationist astronomers suggest alternative theories as a solution to the light travel time problem.

But in the case of V838 Monocerotis, the speed limit of the universe appears to be broken!

It is important to note that the object expanding is not the star itself (or the remnants of the 2002 eruption) but a surrounding shell of nearby interstellar dust (presumably from an earlier eruption).

The shell only appears to expand at a superluminal velocity because the light the dust gives off is a ‘light echo:’ The light originates from the star’s 2002 eruption and is re-radiated by the dust shell. This geometric illusion is further explained by the diagrams in Figure 2 and 3.

Figure 3. In this diagram, the direct light path is labelled 1. 2 to 6 are possible ray paths, reflecting off progressively more distant parts of the dust cloud. Parabolas connect reflection points of ray paths of the same lengths and therefore the same arrival times. All ray paths reflecting from the parabolas give the observer (the Hubble telescope) the illusion that light is travelling perpendicular to the star faster than light speed.

Similar geometric effects produce apparent superluminal motion in radio galaxies, BL Lac objects (active galactic nuclei that emit signals that vary on all time scales and at all frequencies!), quasars and blasars.

So, are the Galaxies moving away from us and don’t seem to be moving apart ? Whereas, this Star exploded sideways?

Can you help me?

I am unsure that I understand the question, but I will try:

Galaxies do appear to be moving away from us and the Bible describes a stretching of the heavens: Psalm 104:2, Isaiah 42:5; 44:24; 45:12; 48:13; 51:13 51:16; Jeremiah 10:12; 51:15; Zechariah 12:1.

The universe appears to be expanding in all directions, in a similar way, stars explode in all directions.

I hope this helps.


References and notes

  1. Although some physicists have proposed physical mechanisms for the speed of light to change up until 4 billion years ago (Big Bang time): Barrow, J., Sandvik, H., and Magueijo, J., Behavior of varying-alpha cosmologies, Phys. Rev. D 65: 063504 February 2002. Return to text.
  2. It is predicted that a theory of quantum gravity (yet to be discovered) will give a naturalistic explanation of the universe before the Planck time. But the evolutionists’ problem of causality will still exist: Something cannot come from nothing. Therefore, miracles are required. Return to text.

Helpful Resources

Dismantling the Big Bang
by Alex Williams, John Hartnett
US $17.00
Soft Cover